Every rating revision, on the record
Ratings change — when the rubric improves, when evidence arrives, when we were wrong. Each change lands here with the old number, the new number, and the reason. The register is append-only: revisions are recorded, never erased. 328 entries to date.
Reason codes
- rubric-v1
- First calibrated grading — the claim's first number under rubric v1 (mechanism × documentation weight).
- rubric-v2
- Rubric v2 migration — the headline became the product of two bars: the Miracle Meter (if the facts are true, could nature do this?) × Evidence (did it happen as reported?).
How the bars and the headline work is defined on the methodology page.
2026-06-12
5 revisions
- The Mosques Left Standing — Banda Aceh 2004 and Palu 2018—→2%first grade
initial-v2 · Initial grading under rubric v2 at publication
- Sascha Roth and the Trial Where Every Tumor Vanished (2022)—→3%first grade
initial-v2 · Initial grading under rubric v2 at publication
- Boden Allen and Buford — A Ranch Dog Walks a Toddler Home (2025)—→4%first grade
initial-v2 · Initial grading under rubric v2 at publication
- Máximo Napa Castro — 95 Days Adrift, Praying to the End (2024–2025)—→4%first grade
initial-v2 · Initial grading under rubric v2 at publication
- Jonah Handler and Nicholas Balboa — A Voice in the Surfside Rubble (2021)—→3%first grade
initial-v2 · Initial grading under rubric v2 at publication
2026-06-11
323 revisions
- The Incorrupt Body of Francis Xavier in Goa6%→3%↓3
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Alice Wigglesworth: The Healer's Deaf Daughter Never Healed5%→13%↑8
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Vittorio Micheli: Pelvic Sarcoma Healed — Bone Reconstruction Documented by X-ray68%→63%↓5
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Vincent de Paul — The Skeleton in a Wax Shell4%→3%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Valeria Valverde: Severe Brain Trauma Resolves After Pilgrimage to Carlo Acutis Tomb52%→47%↓5
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Valentine Greatrakes 'The Stroker'17%→13%↓4
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Bleeding Madonna of Trevignano Romano — DNA, a Negative Ruling, and a Fraud Trial (2016–2024)2%→3%↑1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Todd Bentley's Lakeland Revival Healing Claims (2008)5%→4%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Eucharistic Miracle of Tixtla, Mexico (2006)12%→22%↑10
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Tim Shaddock and Bella — Months Adrift in the Pacific, Found by a Tuna Boat's Helicopter (2023)5%→4%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Thich Quang Duc's Unburnt Heart (1963)11%→10%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Therese Neumann: Inedia and Stigmata8%→16%↑8
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- STEPP Study — Proximal Intercessory Prayer and Sensory Improvement in Mozambique (2010)15%→12%↓3
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- St. Seraphim of Sarov — Healings at Canonization and the Question of Incorruptibility15%→5%↓10
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Incorrupt Relics of St. John Maximovitch of Shanghai and San Francisco23%→15%↓8
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Liquefaction of the Blood of St. Januarius, Naples17%→10%↓7
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Eucharistic Miracle of Sokółka, Poland (2008)21%→11%↓10
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Smith Wigglesworth's Claimed Resurrections from the Dead (1900s-1940s)6%→8%↑2
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Sister Wilhelmina Lancaster — The Intact Body of Gower, Missouri (2019–2023)12%→10%↓2
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Sister Bernadette Moriau: 70th Lourdes Miracle — Cauda Equina Syndrome Resolved62%→55%↓7
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Silkyara Tunnel Rescue — 41 Workers, 17 Days, and the Deity at the Door (2023)8%→7%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Eucharistic Miracle of Siena — Incorrupt Hosts (1730)23%→9%↓14
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Shroud of Turin21%→14%↓7
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Sha'Kyra Aughtry and Joey White — Heard Above the Blizzard (2022)8%→7%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Serge Perrin: Recurring Hemiplegia and Ocular Lesions Healed at Lourdes19%→13%↓6
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Sathya Sai Baba's 'Materializations': Investigated and Exposed2%→3%↑1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Sathya Sai Baba: Materialization Miracles Exposed as Sleight of Hand on Video3%→4%↑1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Eucharistic Miracle of Santarém9%→1%↓8
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Saint Zita of Lucca — Natural Mummification After 700 Years5%→3%↓2
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Saint Silvan — Oldest 'Incorrupt' Body Is Actually a Wax Sculpture4%→3%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Saint Cecilia — The 1599 Discovery and Maderno's Sculpture8%→2%↓6
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Saint Rita of Cascia — Six Centuries of Wax-Repaired Preservation10%→3%↓7
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Resurrection of Jesus: Historiographical Assessment20%→6%↓14
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Pope John XXIII — 'Remarkably Well Preserved,' Not Miraculous4%→3%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Pieter De Rudder: Eight-Year Open Leg Fracture Healed Instantly14%→13%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Panagia Soumela Icon — Exile, Concealment, and Recovery11%→4%↓7
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Pam Reynolds: Veridical NDE During Brain Surgery25%→20%↓5
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Padre Pio's Stigmata38%→26%↓12
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Padre Pio's Bilocation8%→6%↓2
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Padre Pio — Chemical Embalming, Not Incorruption4%→3%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Our Lady of Zeitoun (Cairo Luminous Apparitions)33%→24%↓9
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Our Lady of Pontmain14%→6%↓8
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Our Lady of Las Lajas (Miraculous Image in Stone)9%→1%↓8
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Our Lady of La Salette19%→9%↓10
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Our Lady of Kibeho23%→15%↓8
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Tilma's Eyes: Reflected Figures Claim7%→8%↑1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Our Lady of Guadalupe (The Tilma of Juan Diego)26%→8%↓18
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Our Lady of Akita: Weeping Wooden Statue30%→29%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Our Lady of Akita (Weeping and Bleeding Statue)26%→23%↓3
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Odor of Sanctity10%→2%↓8
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Myrrh-Streaming Orthodox Icons: The Modern Phenomenon10%→3%↓7
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Munira Abdulla — Speaking Again After 27 Years in a Minimally Conscious State (2018)8%→7%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Mucutuy Children — Four Siblings Survive 40 Days in the Amazon (2023)12%→11%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Montreal Iveron Myrrh-Streaming Icon and Brother Jose Munoz-Cortes22%→13%↓9
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Monica Besra: Abdominal Tumor Disappears After Mother Teresa Medal25%→12%↓13
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Miracle of the Sun at Fátima34%→20%↓14
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Miracle Baby — the story behind Miracles Jar19%→5%↓14
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Melissa Villalobos: Placental Abruption Bleeding Stops Instantly After Newman Prayer60%→51%↓9
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Medjugorje 'Miracle of the Sun'5%→6%↑1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Our Lady of Medjugorje (Ongoing Alleged Apparitions)12%→9%↓3
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Matteo Pio Colella: Full Recovery from Fulminant Bacterial Meningitis49%→41%↓8
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Mary of Ágreda's Bilocation to the Americas14%→19%↑5
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Marthe Robin's Fifty-Year Inedia8%→5%↓3
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Marolyn Ford: Instantaneous Vision Restoration After Juvenile Macular Degeneration45%→29%↓16
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Sister Marie Simon-Pierre: Parkinson's Reversed After John Paul II Prayer49%→37%↓12
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Marie Bigot: Blindness, Deafness, and Hemiplegia All Resolved53%→43%↓10
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Marie Bailly: Tuberculous Peritonitis Vanishes Before a Nobel Laureate48%→31%↓17
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Máriapócs Weeping Icon31%→23%↓8
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Maria's Shoe: The Tennis Shoe NDE18%→4%↓14
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Margaret of Cortona — 700 Years in a Crystal Reliquary13%→3%↓10
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Marcilio Haddad Andrino: Brain Abscesses Resolve Before Surgery After Mother Teresa Prayer58%→47%↓11
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Weeping Madonna of Civitavecchia: Blood Matched to a Local Man's DNA4%→3%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Lourdes Cure of Jean-Pierre Bély31%→27%↓4
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Our Lady of Lourdes (Bernadette Soubirous)25%→20%↓5
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Louis Bouriette: Quarryman's Blinded Eye Restored29%→12%↓17
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Baby Lily Groesbeck — The 'Help Me' Voice at the Spanish Fork River (2015)15%→11%↓4
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Lewis Roberts — Breathing Hours Before His Organs Were to Be Donated (2021)8%→4%↓4
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Eucharistic Miracle of Legnica, Poland (2013)24%→12%↓12
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Eucharistic Miracle of Lanciano16%→3%↓13
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Kursk Root Icon of the Sign — Survival, Travels, and Diaspora30%→23%↓7
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Kathryn Kuhlman's Spinal Cancer Healing (Nolen Follow-up)5%→4%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Our Lady of Knock18%→9%↓9
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Juan Gutiérrez: Complete Achilles Tendon Tear Heals After Frassati Novena58%→48%↓10
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Joseph of Cupertino's Levitations15%→6%↓9
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- John Vianney (Curé d'Ars) — Dried Body, Wax Mask, Incorrupt Heart13%→4%↓9
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- John Traynor: WWI Wounded Sailor Walks — The 71st Recognized Miracle60%→53%↓7
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- John Smith — Heart Restarted After 15 Minutes Under a Frozen Lake (2015)11%→9%↓2
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Joan of Arc 'Relics' — Confirmed 20th-Century Forgery2%→1%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Jeni Stepien — Walked Down the Aisle by Her Father's Heart (2016)3%→2%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Jeanne Fretel: Eleven-Year Tubercular Peritonitis Resolved at Eucharistic Procession52%→46%↓6
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Jansenist Convulsionnaires of Saint-Medard12%→9%↓3
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- James Fulton Engstrom: Stillborn 61 Minutes, Full Recovery — Fulton Sheen's Miracle71%→62%↓9
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Jake Finkbonner: Flesh-Eating Bacteria Arrested After Kateri Tekakwitha Relic45%→37%↓8
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Deacon Jack Sullivan: Debilitating Spinal Stenosis Resolved After Newman Prayer43%→35%↓8
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Manchester 'Allah Fish': Arabic Writing on Animal Markings5%→7%↑2
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Inedia (Living Without Food): Systematic Evidence Review4%→3%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Holy Fire of Jerusalem — Holy Saturday at the Holy Sepulchre10%→9%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Hobbs, New Mexico Weeping Virgin Mary (2018)5%→7%↑2
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Hemorrhoissa: Healing of the Woman with the Issue of Blood11%→3%↓8
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Heidi Baker / Iris Global: Healing Claims in Mozambique17%→9%↓8
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Hawaiian Iveron Myrrh-Streaming Icon (2007)12%→3%↓9
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Gemma Galgani's Stigmata and Ecstasies15%→10%↓5
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Gabriel Gargam: Railroad Accident Survivor Walks After Two Years Bedridden55%→49%↓6
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Miracles of Francis Xavier and the Growth of His Legend5%→4%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Stigmata of Francis of Assisi20%→7%↓13
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Floribeth Mora Díaz: Inoperable Brain Aneurysm Disappears After John Paul II Beatification58%→52%↓6
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Evasio Ganora: Terminal Hodgkin's Lymphoma Cured at Lourdes Baths33%→23%↓10
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Elisa Aloi: Ten Years of Bone Tuberculosis Healed at Lourdes49%→43%↓6
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Edeltraud Fulda: Addison's Disease Cured at Lourdes43%→31%↓12
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Dybbuk Possession in Jewish Tradition10%→5%↓5
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Delizia Cirolli: Ewing's Sarcoma Vanishes Months After Lourdes Visit52%→48%↓4
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Delia Knox — Claimed Walking Recovery After 22 Years of Paralysis (2010)13%→3%↓10
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Delhi Monkey Man: Mass Hysteria as Supernatural Belief2%→6%↑4
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Daniel Ekechukwu: Claimed Resurrection at a Reinhard Bonnke Crusade, Nigeria 200112%→4%↓8
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Cottingley Fairies: A Photographic Hoax Confessed 65 Years Later4%→2%↓2
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Our Lady of Warraq — Cairo Apparition, December 200917%→8%↓9
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Our Lady of Assiut — Coptic Marian Apparitions, 2000-200122%→13%↓9
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Consiglia De Martino: Ruptured Thoracic Duct Heals Before Surgery71%→66%↓5
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Chris Gunderson — 16 Years of Feeding-Tube Dependence Resolved After Prayer (2011)40%→36%↓4
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Charbel Makhlouf — The Fluid-Exuding Monk of Lebanon22%→8%↓14
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Cecilia Maribel Flores: HELLP Syndrome Recovery — Oscar Romero's Canonization Miracle28%→19%↓9
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Catherine Labouré — Blue Eyes After 57 Years20%→11%↓9
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Sister Caterina Capitani: Gastric Fistula Healed After John XXIII Relic49%→35%↓14
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Candela Giarda: Catastrophic Childhood Encephalopathy Resolved — John Paul I's Miracle54%→39%↓15
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Calanda Miracle: A Restored Leg36%→37%↑1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Eucharistic Miracle of Buenos Aires (1996)17%→16%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Buddhist Sarira: Crystal Relics from Cremated Masters15%→8%↓7
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Reinhard Bonnke's Africa Crusade Healing Claims (General Pattern)8%→2%↓6
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Eucharistic Miracle of Bolsena-Orvieto (1263)9%→13%↑4
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Blessed Imelda Lambertini — The Child Who Died at First Communion9%→1%↓8
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Bethel Church Fails to Heal Apologist Nabeel Qureshi of Stage-4 Cancer (2017)4%→2%↓2
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Incorruptibility of Bernadette Soubirous10%→8%↓2
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Benny Hinn: HBO and NBC Dateline Investigations Find No Verified Healings5%→4%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Bede's Account of the Miracles of St. Cuthbert9%→8%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Our Lady of Beauraing (The Golden Heart)21%→12%↓9
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Barbara Cummiskey Snyder — Multiple Sclerosis Remission (1981)40%→25%↓15
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Our Lady of Banneux (Virgin of the Poor)16%→7%↓9
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Baby Aya — Born Beneath the Rubble of Jindires (2023)7%→5%↓2
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The AWARE Studies: Prospective NDE Testing8%→7%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Healing of Paulus and Palladia at Hippo (Augustine, City of God 22.8)13%→7%↓6
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Augustine's Catalogue of Miracles in City of God, Book 2211%→4%↓7
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Apollonius of Tyana: The Resurrection of a Roman Girl7%→1%↓6
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Miracles of Apollonius of Tyana7%→6%↓1
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Antonis Mavropoulos — Two Minutes Late for Flight ET302 (2019)4%→2%↓2
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Antonietta Raco: Primary Lateral Sclerosis Healed — The 72nd Recognized Miracle72%→63%↓9
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Ann O'Neill — Acute Lymphocytic Leukemia Remission (1952)35%→26%↓9
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Angela of Foligno — Medieval Mystic, Questionable Preservation Claim9%→1%↓8
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Amanda Paola: Unborn Baby Survives Against All Odds — Paul VI's Canonization Miracle31%→16%↓15
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Alice Couteault: Multiple Sclerosis Remission at Lourdes Baths25%→20%↓5
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- The Incorrupt Relics of St. Alexander Svirsky — Soviet Examination and Return26%→15%↓11
rubric-v2 · Rubric v2 migration: conditional Miracle Meter × directional Evidence; headline = product
- Youssef Ziadna — The Bedouin Driver Who Drove Back Into the Massacre (October 7, 2023)—→2%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Incorrupt Body of Francis Xavier in Goa—→6%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- W.V. Grant: Faith Healer Exposed by Randi and Convicted of Tax Fraud—→2%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Alice Wigglesworth: The Healer's Deaf Daughter Never Healed—→5%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Vittorio Micheli: Pelvic Sarcoma Healed — Bone Reconstruction Documented by X-ray—→68%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Vishwash Kumar Ramesh — Seat 11A, the Sole Survivor of Air India Flight 171 (2025)—→3%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Vincent de Paul — The Skeleton in a Wax Shell—→4%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Nurse Vilma Wong and Dr. Brandon Seminatore — The Preemie Who Came Back as Her Colleague (2018)—→4%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Vespasian's Healing Miracles in Alexandria—→9%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Valeria Valverde: Severe Brain Trauma Resolves After Pilgrimage to Carlo Acutis Tomb—→52%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Valentine Greatrakes 'The Stroker'—→17%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Uri Geller Fails Controlled Test on The Tonight Show (1973)—→3%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Bleeding Madonna of Trevignano Romano — DNA, a Negative Ruling, and a Fraud Trial (2016–2024)—→2%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Todd Bentley's Lakeland Revival Healing Claims (2008)—→5%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Eucharistic Miracle of Tixtla, Mexico (2006)—→12%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Tim Shaddock and Bella — Months Adrift in the Pacific, Found by a Tuna Boat's Helicopter (2023)—→5%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Thich Quang Duc's Unburnt Heart (1963)—→11%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Therese Neumann: Inedia and Stigmata—→8%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Tham Luang — Twelve Boys, a Meditating Coach, and a Rescue No One Believed In (2018)—→10%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Natural Explanations for Stigmata: Scientific Overview—→4%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- STEPP Study — Proximal Intercessory Prayer and Sensory Improvement in Mozambique (2010)—→15%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- STEP Study: Largest Randomized Prayer Trial Finds No Benefit — and a Backfire Effect—→3%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- St. Seraphim of Sarov — Healings at Canonization and the Question of Incorruptibility—→15%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Incorrupt Relics of St. John Maximovitch of Shanghai and San Francisco—→23%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Liquefaction of the Blood of St. Januarius, Naples—→17%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Spontaneous Remission of Small Cell Lung Cancer Without Treatment (2021 Case Report)—→4%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Spontaneous Cancer Remission: Medicine's Documented Puzzle—→5%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Eucharistic Miracle of Sokółka, Poland (2008)—→21%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Smith Wigglesworth's Claimed Resurrections from the Dead (1900s-1940s)—→6%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Sister Wilhelmina Lancaster — The Intact Body of Gower, Missouri (2019–2023)—→12%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Sister Bernadette Moriau: 70th Lourdes Miracle — Cauda Equina Syndrome Resolved—→62%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Silkyara Tunnel Rescue — 41 Workers, 17 Days, and the Deity at the Door (2023)—→8%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Eucharistic Miracle of Siena — Incorrupt Hosts (1730)—→23%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Shroud of Turin—→21%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Sha'Kyra Aughtry and Joey White — Heard Above the Blizzard (2022)—→8%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Serge Perrin: Recurring Hemiplegia and Ocular Lesions Healed at Lourdes—→19%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Sathya Sai Baba's 'Materializations': Investigated and Exposed—→2%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Sathya Sai Baba: Materialization Miracles Exposed as Sleight of Hand on Video—→3%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Eucharistic Miracle of Santarém—→9%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Saint Zita of Lucca — Natural Mummification After 700 Years—→5%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Saint Silvan — Oldest 'Incorrupt' Body Is Actually a Wax Sculpture—→4%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Saint Cecilia — The 1599 Discovery and Maderno's Sculpture—→8%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Saint Rita of Cascia — Six Centuries of Wax-Repaired Preservation—→10%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Resurrection of Jesus: Historiographical Assessment—→20%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Pope John XXIII — 'Remarkably Well Preserved,' Not Miraculous—→4%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Pieter De Rudder: Eight-Year Open Leg Fracture Healed Instantly—→14%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Peter Popoff's Radio Earpiece Fraud—→2%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Panagia Soumela Icon — Exile, Concealment, and Recovery—→11%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Pam Reynolds: Veridical NDE During Brain Surgery—→25%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Padre Pio's Stigmata—→38%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Padre Pio's Bilocation—→8%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Padre Pio — Chemical Embalming, Not Incorruption—→4%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Our Lady of Zeitoun (Cairo Luminous Apparitions)—→33%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Our Lady of Pontmain—→14%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Our Lady of Las Lajas (Miraculous Image in Stone)—→9%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Our Lady of La Salette—→19%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Our Lady of Kibeho—→23%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Tilma's Eyes: Reflected Figures Claim—→7%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Our Lady of Guadalupe (The Tilma of Juan Diego)—→26%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Our Lady of Akita: Weeping Wooden Statue—→30%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Our Lady of Akita (Weeping and Bleeding Statue)—→26%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Ornish et al. — Prostate Cancer Progression Halted by Lifestyle Intervention (2005)—→3%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Odor of Sanctity—→10%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Myrrh-Streaming Orthodox Icons: The Modern Phenomenon—→10%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Munira Abdulla — Speaking Again After 27 Years in a Minimally Conscious State (2018)—→8%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Mucutuy Children — Four Siblings Survive 40 Days in the Amazon (2023)—→12%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Montreal Iveron Myrrh-Streaming Icon and Brother Jose Munoz-Cortes—→22%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Monica Besra: Abdominal Tumor Disappears After Mother Teresa Medal—→25%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Miracle of the Sun at Fátima—→34%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Miracle Baby — the story behind Miracles Jar—→19%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Melissa Villalobos: Placental Abruption Bleeding Stops Instantly After Newman Prayer—→60%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Medjugorje 'Miracle of the Sun'—→5%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Our Lady of Medjugorje (Ongoing Alleged Apparitions)—→12%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Matteo Pio Colella: Full Recovery from Fulminant Bacterial Meningitis—→49%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Mary of Ágreda's Bilocation to the Americas—→14%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Marthe Robin's Fifty-Year Inedia—→8%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Marolyn Ford: Instantaneous Vision Restoration After Juvenile Macular Degeneration—→45%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Sister Marie Simon-Pierre: Parkinson's Reversed After John Paul II Prayer—→49%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Marie Bigot: Blindness, Deafness, and Hemiplegia All Resolved—→53%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Marie Bailly: Tuberculous Peritonitis Vanishes Before a Nobel Laureate—→48%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Máriapócs Weeping Icon—→31%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Maria's Shoe: The Tennis Shoe NDE—→18%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Margaret of Cortona — 700 Years in a Crystal Reliquary—→13%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Marcilio Haddad Andrino: Brain Abscesses Resolve Before Surgery After Mother Teresa Prayer—→58%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Weeping Madonna of Civitavecchia: Blood Matched to a Local Man's DNA—→4%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Lourdes Cure of Jean-Pierre Bély—→31%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Our Lady of Lourdes (Bernadette Soubirous)—→25%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Louis Bouriette: Quarryman's Blinded Eye Restored—→29%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Baby Lily Groesbeck — The 'Help Me' Voice at the Spanish Fork River (2015)—→15%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Lewis Roberts — Breathing Hours Before His Organs Were to Be Donated (2021)—→8%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Eucharistic Miracle of Legnica, Poland (2013)—→24%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Eucharistic Miracle of Lanciano—→16%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Lahaina 'Miracle House' — The Red Roof That Survived, Explained (2023)—→2%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Kursk Root Icon of the Sign — Survival, Travels, and Diaspora—→30%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Kathryn Kuhlman's Spinal Cancer Healing (Nolen Follow-up)—→5%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Our Lady of Knock—→18%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Katie Lentz and the 'Angel Priest' of Highway 19 — Resolved (2013)—→2%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Juan Gutiérrez: Complete Achilles Tendon Tear Heals After Frassati Novena—→58%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Joseph of Cupertino's Levitations—→15%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- John Vianney (Curé d'Ars) — Dried Body, Wax Mask, Incorrupt Heart—→13%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- John Traynor: WWI Wounded Sailor Walks — The 71st Recognized Miracle—→60%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- John Smith — Heart Restarted After 15 Minutes Under a Frozen Lake (2015)—→11%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Joan of Arc 'Relics' — Confirmed 20th-Century Forgery—→2%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Jeni Stepien — Walked Down the Aisle by Her Father's Heart (2016)—→3%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Jeanne Fretel: Eleven-Year Tubercular Peritonitis Resolved at Eucharistic Procession—→52%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Jansenist Convulsionnaires of Saint-Medard—→12%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- James Fulton Engstrom: Stillborn 61 Minutes, Full Recovery — Fulton Sheen's Miracle—→71%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Jake Finkbonner: Flesh-Eating Bacteria Arrested After Kateri Tekakwitha Relic—→45%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Jahi McMath — A Family's Challenge to the Definition of Brain Death (2013–2018)—→2%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Deacon Jack Sullivan: Debilitating Spinal Stenosis Resolved After Newman Prayer—→43%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Manchester 'Allah Fish': Arabic Writing on Animal Markings—→5%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Inedia (Living Without Food): Systematic Evidence Review—→4%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Holy Fire of Jerusalem — Holy Saturday at the Holy Sepulchre—→10%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Hobbs, New Mexico Weeping Virgin Mary (2018)—→5%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Hemorrhoissa: Healing of the Woman with the Issue of Blood—→11%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Heidi Baker / Iris Global: Healing Claims in Mozambique—→17%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Hawaiian Iveron Myrrh-Streaming Icon (2007)—→12%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Gemma Galgani's Stigmata and Ecstasies—→15%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Gardell Martin — 101 Minutes Without a Pulse, Full Recovery (2015)—→3%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The 1995 Ganesha Milk Miracle—→5%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Gabriel Gargam: Railroad Accident Survivor Walks After Two Years Bedridden—→55%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Miracles of Francis Xavier and the Growth of His Legend—→5%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Stigmata of Francis of Assisi—→20%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Floribeth Mora Díaz: Inoperable Brain Aneurysm Disappears After John Paul II Beatification—→58%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Evasio Ganora: Terminal Hodgkin's Lymphoma Cured at Lourdes Baths—→33%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Gen. Eric Smith — Cardiac Arrest, and a CPR Instructor on the Right Block (2023)—→6%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Elisa Aloi: Ten Years of Bone Tuberculosis Healed at Lourdes—→49%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Edeltraud Fulda: Addison's Disease Cured at Lourdes—→43%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Dybbuk Possession in Jewish Tradition—→10%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Delizia Cirolli: Ewing's Sarcoma Vanishes Months After Lourdes Visit—→52%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Delia Knox — Claimed Walking Recovery After 22 Years of Paralysis (2010)—→13%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Delhi Monkey Man: Mass Hysteria as Supernatural Belief—→2%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Daniel Ekechukwu: Claimed Resurrection at a Reinhard Bonnke Crusade, Nigeria 2001—→12%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Cottingley Fairies: A Photographic Hoax Confessed 65 Years Later—→4%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Our Lady of Warraq — Cairo Apparition, December 2009—→17%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Our Lady of Assiut — Coptic Marian Apparitions, 2000-2001—→22%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Consiglia De Martino: Ruptured Thoracic Duct Heals Before Surgery—→71%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Cock Lane Ghost—→2%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Chris Gunderson — 16 Years of Feeding-Tube Dependence Resolved After Prayer (2011)—→40%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Los 33 — Sixty-Nine Days Under the Atacama and the '34th Miner' (2010)—→8%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Charbel Makhlouf — The Fluid-Exuding Monk of Lebanon—→22%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Cecilia Maribel Flores: HELLP Syndrome Recovery — Oscar Romero's Canonization Miracle—→28%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Catherine Labouré — Blue Eyes After 57 Years—→20%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Sister Caterina Capitani: Gastric Fistula Healed After John XXIII Relic—→49%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Candela Giarda: Catastrophic Childhood Encephalopathy Resolved — John Paul I's Miracle—→54%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Calanda Miracle: A Restored Leg—→36%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Eucharistic Miracle of Buenos Aires (1996)—→17%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Buddhist Sarira: Crystal Relics from Cremated Masters—→15%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Reinhard Bonnke's Africa Crusade Healing Claims (General Pattern)—→8%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Eucharistic Miracle of Bolsena-Orvieto (1263)—→9%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Blessed Imelda Lambertini — The Child Who Died at First Communion—→9%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Olive Heiligenthal — Six Days of Prayer for Resurrection (2019)—→2%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Bethel Church Fails to Heal Apologist Nabeel Qureshi of Stage-4 Cancer (2017)—→4%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Incorruptibility of Bernadette Soubirous—→10%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Benny Hinn: HBO and NBC Dateline Investigations Find No Verified Healings—→5%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Bede's Account of the Miracles of St. Cuthbert—→9%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Our Lady of Beauraing (The Golden Heart)—→21%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Barbara Cummiskey Snyder — Multiple Sclerosis Remission (1981)—→40%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Our Lady of Banneux (Virgin of the Poor)—→16%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Baby Aya — Born Beneath the Rubble of Jindires (2023)—→7%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The AWARE Studies: Prospective NDE Testing—→8%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Healing of Paulus and Palladia at Hippo (Augustine, City of God 22.8)—→13%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Augustine's Catalogue of Miracles in City of God, Book 22—→11%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Audrey Santo's Weeping Oil: Laboratory Analysis Identifies Corn, Soybean, and Animal Fat—→8%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Apollonius of Tyana: The Resurrection of a Roman Girl—→7%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Miracles of Apollonius of Tyana—→7%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Antonis Mavropoulos — Two Minutes Late for Flight ET302 (2019)—→4%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Antonietta Raco: Primary Lateral Sclerosis Healed — The 72nd Recognized Miracle—→72%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Ann O'Neill — Acute Lymphocytic Leukemia Remission (1952)—→35%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Angela of Foligno — Medieval Mystic, Questionable Preservation Claim—→9%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Amanda Paola: Unborn Baby Survives Against All Odds — Paul VI's Canonization Miracle—→31%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- Alice Couteault: Multiple Sclerosis Remission at Lourdes Baths—→25%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
- The Incorrupt Relics of St. Alexander Svirsky — Soviet Examination and Return—→26%first grade
rubric-v1 · First calibrated grading under rubric v1 (two-factor)
Aggregate effects of these revisions — tier distribution, score histograms, anchor compliance — are on the calibration page.